Papers on arXiv solving the same problem at the same time1kekomkine .Qq s0 je
I am little bit curious about the following examples
at least two papers appeared on arxiv at the same day solving one and the same problem.
Have you ever seen such a coincidence? If yes, can you provide the links to that papers?
of course the papers maybe solving one and the same problem in a slightly different generalities, for example, one solved a certain case of the problem, and the other one solved the problem completely.
the authors should be different, for example, it is not allowed that both papers have one and the same person as an author/co-author.
-
3$\\begingroup$ I seem to recall Brian Greene telling a story about his collaborators and him working on the same problem as another group simultaneously, and they ended up synchronizing their arXiv submissions. I'll look up whether my memory is accurate in 2 hours or so. $\\endgroup$ – Michael Engelhardt 12 hours ago
-
2$\\begingroup$ I think this question should be community-wiki: is that OK with you? $\\endgroup$ – Yemon Choi 10 hours ago
-
2$\\begingroup$ I believe this happened with the Ellenberg/Gijswijt papers in the Ellenberg-Gijswijt-Croot-Lev-Pach breakthrough on the capset problem. $\\endgroup$ – Sam Hopkins 10 hours ago
-
$\\begingroup$ @YemonChoi, yes, this is completely fine. Please feel free to make it community-wiki. $\\endgroup$ – Paata Ivanishvili 10 hours ago
-
$\\begingroup$ I once did this in agreement with the "concurrent" team (I don't know if "one and the same problem", however there was a significant intersection). $\\endgroup$ – YCor 1 hour ago
2 Answers
I presume the OP is looking for examples from mathematics. Here is one:
Hadrien De March, Nizar Touzi: Irreducible convex paving for decomposition of multi-dimensional martingale transport plans (submitted February 27, 2017, at 14.23 hours)
Jan Obłój, Pietro Siorpaes: Structure of martingale transports in finite dimensions (submitted February 27, 2017, at 18.52 hours)
The second paper explains:
Finally we note that we have hoped to make this paper publicly available only after having proved Conjecture 1.3. However we have been recently made aware of a parallel and independent work of De March and Touzi who study the same problem and obtain similar results using different techniques. Consequently, we have agreed to simultaneously make our works publicly available.
Brian Greene, in his book "The Elegant Universe" on p. 280 (I'm looking at the original 1999 edition as far as I can tell), writes:
"In January 1993, Witten and the three of us released our papers simultaneously to the electronic Internet archive through which physics papers are immediately made available worldwide. The two papers described, from our widely different perspectives, the first examples of topology-changing transitions - the technical name for the space-tearing processes we had found. The long-standing question about whether the fabric of space can tear had been settled quantitatively by string theory."
The papers in question are hep-th/9301042 and hep-th/9301043, both submitted on January 12, 1993.
-
1$\\begingroup$ I still have a vague feeling that there might another example - my initial recollection wasn't of the paragraph quoted, but of a very concrete account of people sitting at keyboards simultaneously hitting submit ... $\\endgroup$ – Michael Engelhardt 8 hours ago
-
$\\begingroup$ I may be pedantic, but with respect to OP's wording, is there a "solving the same problem" here, or just similarly timed development of a theory? $\\endgroup$ – MyNinthAccount 8 hours ago
-
$\\begingroup$ These papers solve a quite concrete problem, namely, provide a description of a process in which the topology of space-time changes in string theory. No such process had been previously constructed. So it seems to me that this is not some vague general parallel development, but the solution of a definite problem. $\\endgroup$ – Michael Engelhardt 8 hours ago